Project management software with Gantt charts: what a real schedule needs

On this page

Short answer: many tools draw bars on a timeline. A real Gantt chart is a schedule: it knows how tasks depend on each other, which days are working days, and what moves when something slips. Test that, not the look.

What a Gantt chart must do beyond drawing bars

  1. Dependencies with lag. Finish-to-start is the common case, but you need start-to-start, finish-to-finish and start-to-finish too, plus lead and lag.
  2. Automatic rescheduling. Change one task and everything that depends on it moves.
  3. A working calendar. Weekends and holidays are respected, so a task that spans a weekend takes the right number of working days.
  4. Constraints. "Must finish on", "start no earlier than" and similar rules that the schedule honours.
  5. Baseline and critical path. You can save the original plan, compare it with the forecast, and see the chain of tasks that decides the finish date.

Three tests for any demo

Use your own plan, or a ten-task example, and do these live:

  1. Slip one task by a week. Do the dependent tasks move on their own? Does the project finish date change?
  2. Add a holiday. Does a task that spans it get longer?
  3. Ask for the critical path. Is it shown, with its length, and does it change when you slip a task?

If the vendor cannot do these in a minute each, it is a drawing tool.

A worked example

Take a small plan: Design (5 days) leads to Build (10 days) and Test (5 days), then Release.

If a tool behaves this way without you touching the dependent tasks, it is scheduling.

Gantt with cost: a quick note on earned value

Dates alone do not tell you whether the project is healthy. Earned value compares what you planned to have done, what you actually did and what it cost: planned value, earned value, actual cost, and the indices CPI and SPI. A CPI below 1 means you are over budget for the work done, and an SPI below 1 means you are behind schedule. Look for a tool that computes these from the plan rather than asking you to enter them by hand.

How NUSK handles it

When to stay on MS Project

If you need resource levelling, effort-driven scheduling and per-resource calendars at a large scale, a dedicated scheduling engine may serve you better. See our guide to Microsoft Project alternatives for how to decide.

Watch the demo · Import your plan

See it with your own project

Import a plan or a Jira project into a free NUSK workspace and judge it on your own data.

↑ Back to top  ·  All articles

Keep reading