Microsoft Project alternatives: how to move your plan without retyping it

On this page

Short answer: you can leave MS Project without rebuilding your schedules. Save the plan as XML (File > Save As > XML), import it into a tool that reads the MS Project XML format, and check the result against a short list. Tasks, hierarchy, dependencies, dates and the working calendar usually come across. Resource rates, task-level calendars and custom fields usually do not. Whether the move is worth it depends on what you need from the new tool, so start there.

Why teams look for an alternative

The reasons we hear most often are practical, not ideological:

If none of these apply to you, MS Project may still be the right tool. We cover that at the end.

What to check in any alternative

Do not judge a scheduling tool by how its Gantt chart looks. Check how it behaves. Ask for a demo with your own plan and test these:

Check What good looks like
Dependencies All four link types (finish-to-start, start-to-start, finish-to-finish, start-to-finish) with lag
Rescheduling Slip one task and everything that depends on it moves, on its own
Calendars Working days and holidays respected; a task that spans a weekend takes the right number of days
Constraints "Must finish on", "start no earlier than" and similar, honoured by the schedule
Baseline You can save the original plan and compare it with the forecast later
Critical path The longest chain of dependent tasks is shown, with its length
Cost Budget and actual cost per task, and earned value if you report it
Import and export A way in from MS Project and a way back out, so you are not locked in
Mixed methods Tasks, deliverables and milestones next to agile items if you need both

Run the "slip one task" test first. A chart that does not reschedule is a drawing, not a plan.

How a plan moves across

MS Project can save a plan in an open XML format (MSPDI). That is the usual bridge to other tools. The older binary .mpp file is not the same thing, and most alternatives, including ours, do not read it directly. Save as XML first:

  1. In MS Project, choose File > Save As and pick XML Format.
  2. Open your new tool's import for MS Project XML and upload the file.
  3. Review the result and the warnings the importer shows.

In NUSK, the import reads the following from the XML file:

A plan of up to 20,000 tasks imports in one go. Links that point at tasks which were not imported are skipped, and the import tells you which ones.

What does not carry over

Be ready for these gaps. They are typical of any move away from MS Project, not just ours:

Do a pilot first. Import one real plan, then compare the old and new Gantt chart side by side, the finish date and the critical path. If the finish date moves by more than a day or two, check the calendar and the constraints before blaming the tool.

Going back out

Lock-in worries are fair. NUSK can export a project as MS Project XML, with the outline, dates, milestones, dependencies, working calendar and assignees, so a plan can be opened in MS Project again. MS Project recalculates the schedule when it opens the file. Test the round trip on a copy before you rely on it.

What you gain: the rest of the project, not just the chart

A scheduling tool is more useful when the plan sits next to the things that decide whether it succeeds:

When MS Project is still the right tool

Be honest with yourself. Stay on MS Project if:

NUSK is a better fit when many people must update the plan, when the data must stay on your own infrastructure, when you mix fixed-date and agile work, or when you want cost, risk and schedule in one view. It is not a replacement for deep resource levelling.

Try it with your own plan

The quickest test costs you ten minutes. Save a real plan as XML, import it into a new project, and run the checks above: slip one task, read the critical path, compare the finish date. If the result matches, you have your answer.

Import your plan into NUSK

See it with your own project

Import a plan or a Jira project into a free NUSK workspace and judge it on your own data.

↑ Back to top  ·  All articles

Keep reading